We need to talk about the internet’s movie takes, because frankly, things have officially gone too far.

On the latest episode of the Cineformation podcast, Trey walked the guys through a definitive, crowdsourced list of the Top 10 Most Overrated Movies of All Time.

We went into this thinking we’d see some reasonable targets. Instead, what followed was 15 minutes of pure, unadulterated chaos, escalating arguments, and Corey threatening to shut down the entire show out of sheer disrespect for cinema history.

The Contenders (In No Particular Order)

To keep the stakes high and let you play along without spoilers, we aren’t going to give away the exact rankings just yet. But to give you an idea of the absolute madness we were dealing with, here are the films that made the internet's Top 10: (In No Particular Order)

Avatar

The Dark Knight

Black Panther

Titanic

The Wizard of Oz

The Lion King

Frozen

The Hunger Games

Twilight

Forrest Gump

Yes, You Read That Right.

The Dark Knight? Forrest Gump? The Lion King?!

When Trey revealed that Black Panther sat comfortably at number five, the studio nearly imploded. And don't even get us started on what the internet decided to put at the absolute number-one spot—or the brutal logic used to tear down The Wizard of Oz (apparently, "90% of it is just characters walking around and singing").

What exactly defines an "overrated" movie? Is it a box office giant that didn’t live up to the astronomical hype, or are people just hating on cult classics for the sake of it? We broke down the exact metrics, debated what "overrated" truly means, and tried to figure out who we need to contact to get this list legally wiped from the internet.

How Would You Rank Them?

Do you actually think Titanic is trash, or is the internet entirely wrong? You’re going to want to hear our live reactions and the exact justifications for these slots.

Check out the full conversation in the episode below to see where these iconic films actually landed—and see if you agree with our breakdown.

🎁 Play Live & Win Real Prizes!

This is just a taste of what we do. We play trivia, debate hot takes, and rank the unrankable live with our community every week. If your movie knowledge is sharp enough, you can walk away with actual prizes. Don't just read the recaps after the fact—join the room, hang out with the crew, and get in on the action.